Kayak/Canoe Holder - will 2 fit side by side?

**Andy Schmidt** · 10-11-2010, 08:48 PM

Hi,

Volvo has two different kayak holders for the wing cross bars. One has the kayak in a laying flat position - and it looks to me as if it would only fit ONE kayak in that position.

The other one has the kayak in a steep vertical angled position. Will TWO of those fit side by side? I can't tell from the photo and there simply are no measurements to give me any indication?

Best Regards,
Andy

**Art** · 10-12-2010, 10:24 AM

Andy,

Any idea of what the gain/decrease in width is with the 2nd gen wing bars?

The wing profile bars really limit the width of workable load space (33") that you have. It really boils down to the beam of your boats. I also have doubts that two kayaks would fit side-by-side using two sets of traditional saddles.

I'm barely able to car top a pair of 22" wide boats using 50" square-profile bars and I have a little more than 37" of workable space on those bars. For wider loads, I have a set of 58" bars that I have at my disposal just in case.

You just might be able to get away with using one set of saddles and a pair of J cradles. Again, it depends on the beam of the boat resting on the saddles.

Pretty sure that you would be okay with two pairs of the folding J cradles, although you might need to attach each cradle as far outward on the bars as possible.

**Andy Schmidt** · 10-12-2010, 10:35 AM

Hi Art,

thanks for posting these photos. That's extremely helpful.

I had not considered combining 1 set of J-cradles and 1 set of saddles. Other than cost, is there any advantage of that combination vs. just using 2 sets of J-cradles?

Are the saddles easier to use or to secure than the J-cradles?

PS: Both Kayaks are one-seaters and one of them is a junior size (for my 10-year old). Thus far we only carried one (and only very locally), so I just strapped it no the cross-wings). Now that we're getting a second one and we might go a little further, I need a more proper setup.

Best Regards,
Andy

**Art** · 10-12-2010, 04:43 PM

Originally Posted by Andy Schmidt

Hi Art,

thanks for posting these photos. That's extremely helpful.

I had not considered combining 1 set of J-cradles and 1 set of saddles. Other than cost, is there any advantage of that combination vs. just using 2 sets of J-cradles?

Are the saddles easier to use or to secure than the J-cradles?

PS: Both Kayaks are one-seaters and one of them is a junior size (for my 10-year old). Thus far we only carried one (and only very locally), so I just strapped it no the cross-wings). Now that we're getting a second one and we might go a little further, I need a more proper setup.

Best Regards,
Andy

In my particular case I already had two sets of saddles so I only needed the one pair of J-cradles to accommodate the beamier of the two boats. Saddles would be the less expensive route and would likely offer the most stable platform for kayaks (less exposure to wind) although I've never had any issues with my J-cradles, even at highway speeds. Mine are the earlier versions and do not fold down.

Cross shop the Volvo and Thule Pro J-cradles for price comparison. It's likely the Volvo branded cradles are, in fact, made by Thule.

NOTE: As I don't know the dimensions for your boats, you may also want to check their hull depths to ensure that they will fit securely on the J-cradles.

**budrichard** · 10-17-2010, 07:19 AM

Two sea kayaks will not fit side by side in the upright position unless you get bars that extend past the mounts by quite a bit.
For normal bars, one must be canted on j type cradles or saddles.
I have Yakima bars and a set of 'Hully Rollers' and a set of Yakima saddles. To fit both sea kayaks, i had to mount one set of attachments outboard of the rail on one side and cant the kayak in the cradles, worked fine.-Dick

**Art** · 10-17-2010, 08:33 AM

Originally Posted by budrichard

Two sea kayaks will not fit side by side in the upright position unless you get bars that extend past the mounts by quite a bit.
For normal bars, one must be canted on j type cradles or saddles.
I have Yakima bars and a set of 'Hully Rollers' and a set of Yakima saddles. To fit both sea kayaks, i had to mount one set of attachments outboard of the rail on one side and cant the kayak in the cradles, worked fine.-Dick

It really depends on the beam of your boats. As previously mentioned, I'm able to car top two singles on standard 50" square-profile load bars. This probably couldn't be done with wider kayaks ie those with 23" + beams. I utilize some older versions of saddles (H2Go) made by Thule.

**Andy Schmidt** · 10-12-2010, 10:42 AM

>> Any idea of what the gain/decrease in width is with the 2nd gen wing bars? <<

You mean between the 2006 and 2008 model years? It's two years ago, but if I remember, it was so VERY minor that I coulnd't believe that the old Wings weren't fitting by a hair (probably a centimeter or less). When I got the new ones they looked and functioned EXACTLY the same - but they clearly had a different part number and they DID specify that they were specific for the new model years.

I was able to sell the old ones on eBay.

When my 2011 T6 arrives in December, I'll see if my current Wings can still be used...

Best Regards,
Andy

**MartinK** · 10-21-2010, 09:13 AM

I use the Kari-Tek J bars and have been pleased so far. See http://www.karitek.co.uk/kbyre/acata...cks.html#aCRJX

We have P&H Scorpio (a 168 for wifey, and a 170 for me) Sea Kayak's. The P&H website recommends J bars (or at least carrying on the sides, not flat)...see this useful video regards car roof carrying...
http://www.phseakayaks.com/videos-loading

Some lovely boats (and cars!) in the photos above

**PJ810** · 11-09-2010, 10:53 PM

Originally Posted by MartinK

...see this useful video regards car roof carrying...
http://www.phseakayaks.com/videos-loading

Don't watch that video if you just read my post about lifting kayaks onto the roof by myself!

Anyway, great video and pleased to hear that loading on the side is the way to go!

I also enjoyed the video on the Scorpio 170 you have.

**budrichard** · 11-10-2010, 08:56 AM

Video is good if you have two people or four hands.
For single person loading, the Yakima Hully Rollers are a dream. I remove one of my rear rubber mats and place on the rear of the top of the XC. From the back I simply raise the front of the kayak on the side of the vehicle until I can move it over and let it rest on the mat on the roof. I then grab in the middle and roll onto the Hully Rollers. Lock the rollers in place and strap and tie down and your good to go.
Simple, one person. least strain on the back.-Dick